Embracing Humanity in Executive Coaching for Better Results with Executives
By Angela Cox, last updated February 12, 2024

In the hushed corridors of corporate life, a vital issue quietly simmers beneath the surface – and it’s the tendency of executives to conceal their true selves, putting on a mask of conformity. This charade, often fueled by societal expectations and corporate pressures, has been quite simply explained through the Pretender Model. As we get into embracing humanity in executive coaching and helping executives through the process, we should try to get a basic idea about it.

So, at Paseda360, we’ve discerned four archetypes within this concept: They are people pleasers, self-persecutors, perfectionists, and persecutors of others. These personas, while seemingly protective, create a complex web inducing stress, burnout, and a concerning lack of fulfilment among executives.

Executive Coaching, a beacon of leadership development, finds itself caught in this web, quite simply being a part of the solution. In other words, the quest for professionalism and a polished image has led many coaches to distance themselves from the very essence of humanity that fosters genuine connections. The need for a more human touch in Executive Coaching has never been more crucial.

It’s not just a matter of professional development either; it’s about unravelling the layers of pretence and unveiling authenticity. So, as we delve into this exploration, we invite you to embark on a journey to unmask the complexities within executive coaching, ultimately leading to a more humane and fulfilling corporate landscape in 2024 through satisfied executive clients.

Corporate Culture: The Impersonal Façade

First up, let’s try to navigate the impersonal façade within the corporate world. With its myriad intricacies, it can sometimes become a breeding ground for the cultivation of pretence. A closer look reveals that this tendency is often born from the pressure to conform to established norms and expectations. The fear of vulnerability and the desire to project an ideal image can lead executives to don the pretender mask, creating an environment that hides authenticity.

Within this system, the quest for success sometimes overshadows the importance of genuine connections and open communication as well. Employees may find themselves navigating a landscape where transparency takes a back seat, and the corporate mask becomes a shield against the perceived vulnerabilities of authenticity.

The Consequences of Executives Hiding Behind the Pretender Mask

The effects of an impersonal facade within a corporate setting can be far-reaching. When executives hide behind a carefully crafted image, it often results in a lack of trust among team members. This trust deficit can impede collaboration, hinder creativity, and ultimately undermine the overall success of the organisation.

Moreover, the toll on individual well-being is palpable. The constant need to maintain a facade can lead to stress, burnout, and a sense of isolation among employees too. The human aspect of corporate culture, often the driving force behind innovation and productivity, is compromised when authenticity is sacrificed for the sake of conformity.

Coach Training: Navigating Towards Authentic Leadership

In the face of these challenges, the importance of coach training becomes evident. Providing executives with the tools to navigate authenticity, foster genuine connections, and lead with transparency can be a transformative step towards a healthier corporate culture. Coach training equips leaders with the skills to break free from the pretender mask, fostering an environment where openness and collaboration thrive.

The Pitfall of Professionalism in Executive Coaching

At a recent industry conference, a diverse array of executive coaches convened to discuss the evolving landscape of leadership development. Surprisingly, a recurring theme emerged—the inadvertent drift towards an overly professional, detached approach in coaching practices. While striving for excellence and proficiency is commendable, the risk of coaches becoming too ensconced in a rigid, professional facade poses a challenge to the essence of effective coaching—building meaningful connections.

Empathy, a cornerstone of successful coaching, can sometimes take a backseat when a coach’s focus is primarily on upholding an image of unyielding professionalism. The conference discussions echoed the sentiment that true coaching excellence lies not just in imparting knowledge but in understanding the unique human experiences and challenges faced by executives.

The Power Suit Image and Its Impact

The symbolism of the power suit, synonymous with corporate professionalism, can inadvertently contribute to the erosion of empathy and connection within executive coaching relationships. As coaches adopt an external appearance that aligns with the traditional image of authority, the risk of creating a barrier between themselves and their clients increases.

Empathy, a quality essential for fostering trust and understanding, often requires vulnerability—an openness to share and connect on a human level. The power suit image, however, can create a perception of invulnerability, making it challenging for executives to relate to their coaches on a personal level. This dynamic can impede the establishment of a genuine rapport and hinder the effectiveness of the coaching relationship.

The Role of Executive Coaching in Contributing to a Dehumanised Corporate Culture

Executive coaching, when approached with a rigid emphasis on professionalism and a lack of emphasis on empathy and vulnerability, can inadvertently contribute to a dehumanised corporate culture. In an era where the demand for authentic leadership is at its peak, a coaching model that neglects the human element risks perpetuating a culture where executives feel compelled to uphold an impenetrable image, sacrificing authenticity for a facade of infallibility.

It is crucial to recognise that vulnerability, far from being a weakness, is a strength that fosters genuine connections and promotes a culture of openness. Executive coaching, when rooted in empathy and an acknowledgement of vulnerability, has the potential to transform corporate cultures, nurturing leaders who inspire trust, collaboration, and innovation.

Shifting Coaching Paradigms: From Non-Directive to Co-Creation

Co-creation in executive coaching marks a departure from the conventional non-directive model, where coaches typically refrain from offering advice or solutions. Instead, it embraces a collaborative approach where both the coach and the executive actively contribute to the coaching process. This dynamic interaction fosters a sense of shared responsibility and mutual growth.

The essence of co-creation lies in acknowledging that executives are experts in their own experiences and challenges. By inviting them to actively participate in defining goals, exploring solutions, and shaping their developmental journey, coaches unlock a wealth of insights and potential that may remain untapped in a more directive coaching model.

Benefits of Authentic Coaching: Tremendous Outcomes for Clients

Recent research in neuroscience has shed light on the biological effects of authentic coaching on the brain. When individuals engage in authentic conversations and receive genuine support, the brain’s reward system is activated. This, in turn, leads to the release of neurotransmitters such as dopamine and oxytocin, fostering a positive emotional state and strengthening the neural pathways associated with trust and connection.

Moreover, authentic coaching has been linked to the reduction of cortisol, the stress hormone. When clients feel seen, heard, and accepted in a coaching relationship, the body’s stress response diminishes. This biological harmony not only contributes to improved mental well-being but also has a cascading effect on overall physiological health.

Mental Health Impact: Nurturing Emotional Resilience

Authentic coaching goes beyond surface-level discussions; it delves into the emotional landscape of the client. This depth of engagement has been shown to significantly enhance emotional resilience. By encouraging clients to explore and express their authentic selves, coaches contribute to the development of coping mechanisms and emotional regulation skills.

Furthermore, the authenticity inherent in co-creative coaching relationships provides a safe space for clients to confront and process their challenges. This therapeutic aspect of coaching has been associated with reductions in symptoms related to anxiety and depression. The genuine support offered in authentic coaching relationships becomes a powerful catalyst for mental health improvement.

Tangible Outcomes: Performance, Innovation, and Job Satisfaction

Beyond the biological and mental health benefits, authentic coaching yields tangible outcomes in the professional realm. Studies have consistently shown that executives who engage in authentic coaching experience improvements in performance metrics. The collaborative and supportive nature of authentic coaching fosters an environment conducive to innovation, creativity, and problem-solving.

Moreover, authentic coaching has a direct impact on job satisfaction and retention rates. When employees feel authentically supported in their development, they are more likely to be engaged, motivated, and committed to their roles. This, in turn, leads to lower turnover rates and a more stable and productive workforce.

Benefits for Coaches and Executives in Co-Creation

The shift towards co-creation brings about a host of benefits for both coaches and executives too. For coaches, this approach allows for a more nuanced understanding of the executive’s unique context, enabling tailored guidance and support. It also enhances the coach’s adaptability, as they respond to the evolving needs and aspirations of their clients in real time.

Executives, on the other hand, find empowerment in actively contributing to their own development. The co-creation model nurtures a sense of ownership and accountability, fostering a more profound commitment to the coaching process. This approach is particularly effective in cultivating leaders who not only excel in their professional roles but also embody authenticity and emotional intelligence.

The Pivotal Role of Ongoing Coach Training in Facilitating Co-Creation

As the coaching landscape undergoes this paradigm shift, the importance of ongoing coach training cannot be overstated. At Paseda360, we understand this matter all too well. Coaches need to continually refine their skills and adapt their approaches to align with emerging trends and best practices. Incorporating co-creation into coaching requires a nuanced understanding of the dynamics involved, along with the ability to seamlessly integrate this collaborative model into established coaching frameworks.

Coach training programs play a crucial role in equipping coaches with the knowledge, tools, and practical insights needed to navigate the intricacies of co-creation successfully. By staying abreast of the latest research, methodologies, and case studies, our coaches at Paseda360 can enhance your ability to facilitate meaningful, co-creative relationships with respective executive clients.

 Paseda360’s Approach: Cultivating Authentic Coaches

At Paseda360, our approach to coach training isn’t just about techniques; it’s about nurturing authenticity. We believe that a coach’s ability to connect with clients goes beyond mere professionalism—it hinges on being real and understanding oneself deeply. Our philosophy revolves around fostering genuine connections, dismantling the barriers of pretence, and creating coaches who are empathetic, real, and effective.

The Self-Discovery Journey for Coaches: Softening the Edges

We take our coaches on a unique journey of self-discovery. It’s not just about learning coaching methods; it’s about understanding one’s own strengths, weaknesses, and biases. This journey helps coaches soften the edges of their traits, making them more adaptable and relatable. By acknowledging and working on their own growth, our coaches are better equipped to guide others through theirs.

Encouraging Coaches to Shed the Pretender Mask

Pretending has no place in genuine coaching. We encourage our coaches to drop the act and connect authentically with their clients. By doing so, they create a safe space for clients to be themselves. It’s not about projecting an image of invulnerability; it’s about being a real, empathetic human who understands the complexities of personal and professional challenges.

Final Words

So, as we reflect on the intricacies of executive coaching and consider all the facts, one truth stands out—humanity matters. The need for authenticity in coaching goes beyond methodologies and polished images. It’s about connecting at a human level, and understanding that vulnerability is not a weakness but a source of strength. In the stressful system that is corporate life, reclaiming our humanity is the first step towards a more fulfilling and effective coaching experience.

To our executive coaches, the call is clear—reclaim your authenticity. It’s time to shed the pretender mask and redefine coaching for a more human corporate landscape together with Paseda360. Clients don’t need perfect, polished figures; they need real, empathetic guides who understand the challenges they face. So, let’s embark on this journey together, where the power of genuine connection reshapes not just coaching sessions but the very fabric of corporate life.

Ready To Start
Transforming Lives & Building A Sustainable Coaching Business?

Today’s high performers, business owners and executives want transformational change, and you can be the person to help them achieve it as a Paseda360 Practitioner
Our training programmes →